Chapters only indent for branches

Discussion in 'Suggestions' started by RicoLouis, Aug 28, 2017.

  1. RicoLouis

    RicoLouis Really Really Experienced

    Related to this suggestion by Smisenost
    https://forum.chyoa.com/threads/feature-request-collapse-left.1206/#post-16683

    Instead of collapsing ever time a new chapter is added stories with page after page will not indent and instead stack on top of each other like below. If two branches or added then the chapter would indent. Linear stories would be straight down on the story map.

    Chapter 1.1 (Introduction)
    ╠ Chapter 2.1
    ║ Chapter 3.1
    ║ Chapter 4.1
    ║ Chapter 5.1
    ║ Chapter 6.1
    ║ ╠ Chapter 7.1
    ║ ╚ Chapter 7.2
    ╚ Chapter 2.1
     
  2. dingsdongs

    dingsdongs Really Really Experienced

    Why are there two chapters labeled "2.1"?

    And what about the follow up chapters of 7.1 and 7.2? With your suggestion, they would all be on the same level? I'd imagine that this would make it difficult to distinguish different choices from follow up chapters.

    I agree that the current system isn't perfect, especially on mobile, but i'm not convinced that your suggestion is much better.
    Perhaps with a graphical concept and a side by side comparison one could get a better impression and judge the differences.
     
  3. Loeman

    Loeman Really Really Experienced

    I don't know the best way to go about changing it, but the current system is definitely flawed.
     
  4. RicoLouis

    RicoLouis Really Really Experienced

    Human error

    Could be solved by automatic spacing.


    Chapter 1.1 (Introduction)
    ╠ Chapter 2.1
    ║ Chapter 3.1
    ║ Chapter 4.1
    ║ Chapter 5.1
    ║ Chapter 6.1
    ║ ╠ Chapter 7.1
    ║ ║
    ║ ╚ Chapter 7.2

    ╚ Chapter 2.2
     
    Last edited: Aug 30, 2017
  5. Javalar

    Javalar Really Experienced

    That looks like a good solution for linear stories but like a desaster for stories with lots of branches.
     
  6. RicoLouis

    RicoLouis Really Really Experienced

    Before
    [​IMG]

    After
    [​IMG]
     
  7. gene.sis

    gene.sis CHYOA Guru

    looks quite confusing to me
     
  8. mindtheMILF

    mindtheMILF Guest

    Second the motion.
     
  9. RicoLouis

    RicoLouis Really Really Experienced

    It will take a little getting used.
    Secondary option would be for the reader to be able to switch back and forth depending on the story.



    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Aug 31, 2017
  10. dingsdongs

    dingsdongs Really Really Experienced

    The first 7.1 and 7.2 would need a space between them as well according to the proposed rules.
     
  11. mindtheMILF

    mindtheMILF Guest

    This is much better with the lines.
     
    8inchesandcounting likes this.
  12. mindtheMILF

    mindtheMILF Guest

    Going back to this for a moment. Is there a way to show main chapters only at first then you can click on one that will show all the branches that from that chapter. For example 6.1 as shown above has chapters. 6.1 and all chapters within 6.1 would reveal while others could hide.
     
  13. Nemo of Utopia

    Nemo of Utopia CHYOA Guru

    BTW what story is the example taken from? (Because I think I would like to read it...)
     
    mindtheMILF likes this.
  14. RicoLouis

    RicoLouis Really Really Experienced

    Lovecraft chronicles: school days- sadly I couldn't really get into the story and lost interest writing it.
     
  15. lazyhorny

    lazyhorny Virgin

    i like your suggestion RicoLouis because it is relativly similar to how it looked before the mess we have now. the way it was sorted before the current one was way better both in keeping track of where you were in the story and which branch and so on.