Extreme violence rule

Discussion in 'Authors' Hangout' started by GenericEditor168, Jan 31, 2017.

  1. GenericEditor168

    GenericEditor168 Really Really Experienced CHYOA Backer

    What qualifies as extreme violence? If something qualifies as extreme violence, how can I tweak it to not qualify?
     
    raziel83 likes this.
  2. Funatic

    Funatic Really Really Experienced

    Well, one can argue over qualification but i would draw the line somewhere at limbs severing and gut spilling. In a story i did i actually had somebodies arm cut off and to de-escalate it i just used as little gory details as possible. By that i mean i concentrated on where the cut was and how it happened and less on the amount of blood or screams of pain. Makes the scene a little less impactful but in the grand scheme of things it is not that important.
     
  3. RicoLouis

    RicoLouis Really Really Experienced

    I think it it more means violence during sex. So a hero could go around cutting off all the arms he wants to as long as he isn't doing it in the middle of a sex scene. So no violent rape scenes or stuff like that.
     
    RadioGalaxy, Loeman and airwreck like this.
  4. Funatic

    Funatic Really Really Experienced

    I would find it odd if it was limited to sex scenes. Then again i didn't make the rules so i don't know.
     
    raziel83 likes this.
  5. airwreck

    airwreck Really Experienced

    There are a bunch of stories that a fantasy/sci-fi RPGs that your character could kill monsters, which is acceptable.

    Like RicoLouis said, I think the rule applies to violence mixed in with sex.
     
    fyreant, RadioGalaxy and Loeman like this.
  6. GenericEditor168

    GenericEditor168 Really Really Experienced CHYOA Backer

    Hmm... I wasn't going to mix violence with sex, but would full-on, Aztec-style ritual sacrifice be acceptable?
     
  7. Nemo of Utopia

    Nemo of Utopia CHYOA Guru

    I've recently read over the rules again and I think so, but only a mod could say for sure...
     
    Loeman likes this.
  8. Loeman

    Loeman Really Really Experienced

    As others have already said, I believe the rule mainly pertains to sex or the sexualized glorification of extreme violence - with all of those elements being present.

    I go with the basic introduction of the rule - this is not a slasher porn site.

    Put this way - in mainstream fantasy or military or other settings there's violence all the time. I'd assume if the story is at a point where the violence is in a setting where it would be acceptable for mainstream literature, it would be acceptable here.
     
    airwreck likes this.
  9. Loeman

    Loeman Really Really Experienced


    I'm guessing it would depend on the surrounding details.

    There's a good chance it could be acceptable, I'd imagine, and numerous ways in which it could be made unacceptable.

    People generally know porn when they see it. If its a smutty ritualized sacrifice, it will come through that way.

    Like Nemo said, in the end its up to the mods.
     
  10. edwards21

    edwards21 Experienced

    I'm planning a story with a biker gang. Something like that is bound to have a ton of violence, probably some fairly brutal murders. Probably a torture/interrogation element. It's not really something I want to avoid, but at the same time, I don't want to violate the site's rules.

    I'm happy to put up a disclaimer if/when I write the story.
     
    DoAdventures likes this.