This is a really rough idea for a new story: Feedback wanted on the idea. Sexual Hazing The Alpha Sigma Phi was the most exclusive and mysterious fraternities on campus. They were known as an academic fraternity with a reputation for high graduation rates. Their membership process was closely guarded and rumored to be almost impossible. Only 25% of their pledges actually gain acceptance. At the same time the fraternity did not engage in excessive drinking, had never been accused of hazing or abusing pledges and was in general highly regarded as a model fraternity. We follow the pledges. Three possible ideas are: Josh--Straight football stud with 4.0 and a hot cheerleader girlfriend named Sasha Donnie--Outgoing gay man with bi tendencies, no regular sex partner Rob--Straight nerd, very shy, very close to the women in his family. Very little sexual experience with girls. Only a few dates. The pledges find that the hazing ritual consists of completing 10 sexual trials. They are sworn to secrecy and no outsiders may ever know how they gained admittance to the Fraternity. 10 Trials Straight missionary intercourse, cum inside your partner. Doggy style fuck pull out and cum on your partner’s ass Fellatio-Give or Receive, must swallow the ejaculation Cunnilingus--make sure she cums three times Hand job--Must last 30 minutes Tit fuck--ejaculate on her face and tits Anal fuck-Give or receive Dry hump-While dressed hump against another person until you ejacualate Voyeur-film a woman or man masturbating to orgasm Exhibisitonist-Masturbate and ejaculate in front of a group They have three weeks to provide video evidence of each trial being completed.
If they refuse 75% of the pledges, there should be a reason that they had never been accused of hazing like - they refuse all official pledges but there are rumors that they only accept pledges who send them the proof of all trials, - they let the pledges do something really bad/compromising which can be used to command them silence after refusing them, - they exclusively accept legacy pledges who won't tell about the hazing because of their parents (though then the refuse rate would be too high) or - the hazing is something new.
College hazing stories are pretty normal. Perhaps make it harder with doing something sexual with a University staff member, Use of Alcohol in a unique sexual way from your partner(s), and maybe even throw in having sex with three genders.