Post your comments

Discussion in 'CHYOA General' started by Gekkehenk, Jul 27, 2020.

  1. Gekkehenk

    Gekkehenk Virgin

    Well I just had enough of the toxic comments in the story I wrote. So I am just opening up this topic as a wall of shame for the douchebags.

    This is one of the sweet comments I received:

    protoborg 6 hours ago
    The fuck is this?! Were you drunk when you wrote this?

    Once I receive more stupid comments I will keep you guys posted. Feel free to post your own stupid comments in this topic.
     
    AlexandraS90 and insertnamehere like this.
  2. Haoro

    Haoro Really Really Experienced CHYOA Backer

    Yeah I've seen that guy around. He just constantly posts these aggressive, nitpicking comments on lots of different stories. I don't know if he thinks he's being helpful or clever or something, but they're never constructive.
     
  3. HaremStarter

    HaremStarter Really Experienced CHYOA Backer

    I keep my comments to constructive criticism or praise. I don’t feel insults help anyone.
     
    Gatsha and Haoro like this.
  4. wicker

    wicker Really Really Experienced

    yeah, I always think it's weird when people complain in the comments section when they could just write a different better chapter, but the ones who bitch and moan are often not writers.
    It's pet peeve of mine.
    If you can write better, do it!
     
  5. insertnamehere

    insertnamehere Really Really Experienced

    You are not the first to complain about Mr. Borg, and you will surely not be the last. I have read many of his comments that are similarly disrespectful. I don't always disagree with him, but holy shit, it's like he's trying to phrase things in the worst way imaginable.

    That said, criticism is the most useful form of feedback. If a reader can point out flaws in your writing politely, it will only improve your skills.
     
  6. SeriousBrainDamage

    SeriousBrainDamage Really Really Experienced

    Politely, yeah of course.
    Being a little bit caustic should be fair game too, we're all grown up after all.
    If only people knew the difference between a witty comment and a toxic one:rolleyes:
     
    Regin34 and insertnamehere like this.
  7. insertnamehere

    insertnamehere Really Really Experienced

    Yup. 'Joking' implies 'funny'.
     
  8. HaremStarter

    HaremStarter Really Experienced CHYOA Backer

    Making a negative criticism is always tricky as some writers react poorly to even the most well intentioned criticism. I’ve found if you start off with praising something you like About the story it takes the edge off of your complaint. An insult though should in no wise be considered good faith criticism nor is it helpful.