I care about the ideas in my story, for sure. I'll be rather lenient with myself when it comes to descriptions, continuity, and overall writing style because it's not a job, just a hobby.
But, I like my writings, here and elsewhere, because they describe the things I like, and they give me a shot to find others who like these same ideas. So, I care that they can get my overall concepts and scenarios across for the things I enjoy, to put feelers out and discover like-minded people. It's my kink fingerprint, way better defined than just a list of things I enjoy.
And I think that's pretty important, personally. Sex is something that seeks a connection, albeit with a degree of privacy. There are a plethora of ideas out there that turn people on, and that creates a giant, diverse, but diluted field. So, for me, putting my personal enjoyments into a single place hopefully opens some paths to come together with others that really resonate with the ideas beyond the keywords. I definitely think that's worth caring about!