The pants are a minor example, but that's a great demonstration of how hard it can be to track of details within a single story arc; imagine if you had to respect the events of Vain's threads, too? I'm following Vain's threads, and I know I've contradicted them on at least one occasion. I think that's why it's common to repeat certain details like character appearance in narration; you want to be sure the reader can visualize exactly what you intend so that you can't be misinterpreted in subsequent threads.
Oh damn, that's right, you are, and that was only at the mid-50-ish thread, isn't it? Vain is a juggernaut, I swear, I really did try to keep up with his stuff, but after passing the 120 mile marker, I slowed down, I'll be honest. That is a level of detail only seen in long-running fantasy authors like George R. R. Martin or Robert Jordan, and I know I lost track of things in like the fifth book of
Wheel of Time. Brandon Sanderson, in finishing the series, said he was grateful to the extensive notes Jordan left behind (a huge book in their own right) and even had one of his editors be a continuity director, especially since the final book ballooned into three and equally tripled in word count (250,000 to 750,000, yeesh). When you have a universe that detailed, you need something like that, and I agree, emphasizing key points for a collaborative effort is vital.
I generally enjoy Asimov and Turtledove, but I'm more familiar with their short fiction than novels. The form probably keeps their excesses in check!
Oh hell yes,
I, Robot is one of my favorite books, but pick any book from the
Foundation series and it's... not on the same level. Not to knock all of his fiction, I enjoyed
Caves of Steel and
The Naked Sun, but I stopped a
Robots of Dawn because it dragged and, spoilers, I don't read Asimov for erotica. (Making matters worse, the central character, Elijah Bailey, is married but has a fevered sexual fantasy about a woman from the previous novel that goes on for about two pages, and then he contemplates what it would be like to live with her instead of his wife -- and if some rumors I've heard about Asimov at conferences are true, maybe I shouldn't be surprised.) In much of his other novels, Asimov can tend to be quite preachy, and even though those sermons are ones I can get behind, I feel like I'm being browbeaten sometimes.
How Few Remain by Turtledove is excellent, I recommend it just for how well he channels Mark Twain from beyond the grave, but I tried to read one of his recent series,
The War that Came Early, and it's a slog in my opinion. Not for the content, I don't mind a good war novel, but it's not enough to keep my interest. Adding aliens like in
Worldwar makes it fascinating, especially when things get twisted around in unexpected ways (Spoilers: at one point, the Nazis abandon their policy of the Final Solution to redirect all efforts -- and people, including Jews -- to fight the alien invaders, so Turtledove makes you root
for Hitler). In the end, Turtledove's life as a history professor shines through in everything he writes, and so he writes history a Churchill-esque "one damn thing after another" sense, and sometimes it works, while other times it doesn't.
In the same vein of the conversation, I'm reminded of another thing from
On Writing when King states that supports the old idea that you should "write what you know," even though you may not think it entertaining. He gives the example of
Cosmic Engineers by Clifford Simak which is, effectively,
plumbers in space, and that it's pretty good though dated. In that sense, you already know the research, and can make it interesting.
For duskford's "Tales of Silver Lake," I've actually been thinking about another cabin trip that Heather goes on for a few days, but this one is owned by Rohit's family, the Indian teen I've referenced more than once. I had several Indian-American friends in high school, and went to a few of their houses, and so I have this interesting conversation in my head between Heather and Rohit's mother, Bipasha, where she effectively adopts her and pesters her as her own daughter after she and Rohit stop dating. Bipasha sees a lot of herself in Heather in terms of personality and drive -- and of course when Heather demonstrates that she can cook bhindi perfectly, she starts calling her about these nice boys her age she met and that they would make good husbands for her. (Mostly in jest of course. Mostly.) All of that comes from my experience, and besides, I think Heather begrudgingly answering her phone to talk to Bipasha is hilarious.
An abundance, even an overwhelming amount of detail can be useful because it invokes a certain emotional response. The fake documents in
House of Leaves have footnotes that occupy multiple pages and no other text, literally pages on pages full of tiny font about architectural or film history minutia or what have you, because the character writing them has gone out of his mind. And Kris Straub wrote
a short story that doesn't even have a plot, it just demonstrates this machine performing its function. Its creepy, off-putting function that demands absolute secrecy to succeed, and that gets demonstrated on someone who doesn't share your knowledge. (Yes, horror fiction is my touchstone for experimental forms of writing. Gotta keep the reader on their toes!)
Side note first: I love the description of
House of Leaves that a friend gave to another friend -- "It's a book about a book about a movie about a house that doesn't exist." After said second friend read it, she called it more of an art piece than a book, and you put it exactly why that is. I think Mark Danielewski is the only person I know to use detail
itself as a literary device, and by virtue immersing you as a character in the book just by possessing the book, let alone reading it, because you want to be like Johnny Truant and try to figure out the message yourself.
That's the dichotomy I have in mind. Because it is annoying when the narrative is second to showing off how smart you are, and it's definitely the more dangerous possibility in my mind. When I'm writing a historical setting, for instance, I like having a bunch of contemporaneous events and trends influence the backgrounds of my characters, but how much of that does the reader really need to know? Sometimes it feels like I'm just writing, “Look how <PERIOD SETTING> this is!” over and over.
If you're worried about that Patzo, read anything by Neal Stephenson and you'll know what not to do. The man breaks away from the story to go on about organic chemistry or cybernetics or an erotic upholstery story for about 20 pages before picking up back where he left off. Sometimes it's effortless and before I realize that I've been in a lecture, the story is back, but sometimes it's so shoehorned, he was obviously trying to make a point. Again, Stephen Baxter falls into this problem as well, because everyone in his books seems to know everything so the conversation about meteorology or multidimensional physics can go on.
And then you might miss brilliant, stranger-than-fiction details that fit perfectly but you'd never think of on your own. I'd heard Kip Thorne was an advisor on Interstellar but never read this paper before! That's what I'm afraid of missing out on if I don't dig beyond the headline or the Wikipedia summary. And I guess that's a good point as well: I knew about Carl Sagan and Contact as well, but not what the SEE did for Jane Foster in Thor. Don't feel like your stuff is too trifling to risk an email to someone who knows the subject better than you do.
Heh. I just remembered a book festival I attended. At one event a few authors of historical nonfiction were interviewed before an audience, and someone asked them the same question I am now. "How do you know you've done enough research and can begin writing?" And the unanimous answer was, "When my editor calls me in a panic to say my deadline is only X weeks away.” So maybe the answer is to give someone else a calendar and have them scream at me after an arbitrary number of days.
lol, and that' really it. Stop when you have enough of a compelling story on your own. I remember in my text RP days, I asked one of my mother's friends, a former FBI undercover agent, about the kind of criminal activity the FBI was investigating in the 80's. The story we were currently writing involved my character, an alien living on Earth in a facility that was once under the protection of the United States government, being monitored and raided by the new Reagan administration, so my question revolved around what kind of excuse would they need to conduct the raid. He said that anything involving the illegal drug trade would be good, and since my character's facility was in the American southwest, it fit rather well. Then he directed me to a case of a major bust in New Mexico in the 80's he was involved in, so I researched it, tweaked some details, and made that into the event in my story. It worked out beautifully. He works as a TV and movie consultant now for that very reason.
I guess, eventually, at least when it comes to stories like this, you reach a point when you're talking about the decisions people are making on the spot, and at that point, the story begins, regardless of the universe that exists around them.
Except for that. The Wikipedia summaries on any topic around parasitology is more than enough for me. And the pictures...
:3
In a similar vein, I was impressed when art historians figured out that, based on the year Munch claimed to be inspired,
The Scream is based on the multicolored sunsets Europe
following the Krakatoa eruption.
Oh
wow. Amazing, I love it. That's totally like the story behind the creation of Frankenstein, when Mary Shelley, Percy Shelley, John Pollidori, and Lord Byron sat around telling ghost stories during the abnormally cold and miserable summer of 1816, a year after the massive eruption if Mount Tambora in Indonesia which lowered global temperatures because of the ash in the atmosphere. It was even called "
the Year Without a Summer." I love the cultural history of natural events. I really think that's affected our culture and society more than people realize!