Continuity ties into this, researching the progress of the story itself, and I know I've failed at that a few times in "At the Cabin." (Whose pants are these again in the hallway? lolol)
That's a great point in light of Trugbild's idea. If the story doesn't present every alternate thread as an alternate universe or possibility, having to read every single thread to know exactly what's happened so far is a hefty requirement for participation, especially once it hits a certain length. The pants are a minor example, but that's a great demonstration of how hard it can be to track of details within a single story arc; imagine if you had to respect the events of Vain's threads, too?
I'm following Vain's threads, and I know I've contradicted them on at least one occasion. I think that's why it's common to repeat certain details like character appearance in narration; you want to be sure the reader can visualize exactly what you intend so that you can't be misinterpreted in subsequent threads.
Sometimes I think this can go too far to the point where I feel like I'm reading an opinionated textbook rather than a novel, and that defines my love-hate relationship with Stephen Baxter, Neal Stephenson, Isaac Asimov, and Harry Turtledove. There's an author (I cannot think of his name for the life of me) that Stephen King calls in On Writing as basically writing instruction manuals for how things worked, like hotels or airports or cars, that are built around a story. You'd never think that something like that would be entertaining, but he managed to spit out hundreds of books on that formula.
I generally enjoy Asimov and Turtledove, but I'm more familiar with their short fiction than novels. The form probably keeps their excesses in check!
That's the dichotomy I have in mind. Because it is annoying when the narrative is second to showing off how smart you are, and it's definitely the more dangerous possibility in my mind. When I'm writing a historical setting, for instance, I like having a bunch of contemporaneous events and trends influence the backgrounds of my characters, but how much of that does the reader really need to know? Sometimes it feels like I'm just writing, “Look how <PERIOD SETTING> this is!” over and over.
But your Stephen King example, building the narrative around a structure or mechanism and how the narrative springs from every step of that? I
love things like that. An abundance, even an overwhelming amount of detail can be useful because it invokes a certain emotional response. The fake documents in
House of Leaves have footnotes that occupy multiple pages and no other text, literally pages on pages full of tiny font about architectural or film history minutia or what have you, because the character writing them has gone out of his mind. And Kris Straub wrote
a short story that doesn't even have a plot, it just demonstrates this machine performing its function. Its creepy, off-putting function that demands absolute secrecy to succeed, and that gets demonstrated on someone who doesn't share your knowledge. (Yes, horror fiction is my touchstone for experimental forms of writing. Gotta keep the reader on their toes!)
I also feel that researching something for the sake of research can generate very good ideas and stunning imagery for a good story. Think of Interstellar, whose lead scientific advisor, co-writer, and executive producer was acclaimed physicist Kip Thorne and the movie has been described as portrayed the most accurate representation of a black hole based on our current understanding of physics.
And then you might miss brilliant, stranger-than-fiction details that fit perfectly but you'd never think of on your own. I'd heard Kip Thorne was an advisor on
Interstellar but never read this paper before! That's what I'm afraid of missing out on if I don't dig beyond the headline or the Wikipedia summary. And I guess that's a good point as well: I knew about Carl Sagan and
Contact as well, but not what the SEE did for Jane Foster in
Thor. Don't feel like your stuff is too trifling to risk an email to someone who knows the subject better than you do.
Heh. I just remembered a book festival I attended. At one event a few authors of historical nonfiction were interviewed before an audience, and someone asked them the same question I am now. "How do you know you've done enough research and can begin writing?" And the unanimous answer was, "When my editor calls me in a panic to say my deadline is only X weeks away.” So maybe the answer is to give someone else a calendar and have them scream at me after an arbitrary number of days.
Something like this was one inspiration of the erotophilia in "At the Cabin" in the first place, by looking at chemical signaling in the animal kingdom and ecology in general, and by studying very horrible and terrifying parasites in nature (because I don't want Patzo to have flashbacks, anyone interested in that discussion
can look here)
Except for that. The Wikipedia summaries on any topic around parasitology is more than enough for me. And the pictures...
Seriously though, the erotophilia is interesting because it has those signs rooted in natural phenomena.
Art and science have always dovetailed beautifully and strangely (Salvador Dali is my favorite artist because of that), and it feeds into the larger lesson of research in telling fantastic stories.
In a similar vein, I was impressed when art historians figured out that, based on the year Munch claimed to be inspired,
The Scream is based on the multicolored sunsets Europe
following the Krakatoa eruption.