Ok voice message aside. I agree with the outcome like I said. I didn't think the webs would effect Yulia as bad 1, but I also did think that just because she's the front of the line that the others would still help.
I forgot the spear issue, but assumed if in trouble she would ask for a sword. I figured Cherchiel's strength would help her get unstuck if she stepped wrong, but Yulia threw that out.
As for the fight, I agree there was really nothing to be done since Yulia was out of it. As an ambush it is over too fast to actually react to, so it's up to the passive bonuses that we already have. This challenge was lost when we failed the first roll, but i appreciate we had a second roll as a chance.
I would like to say that with these rolls being as high as the are for both paths, I'm not sure what more preparation we could do? Ideally we would like to proceed down a path where we at least have 50 50 odds of success, but right now it's dire in either direction? If we were struggling I wouldn't complain, but after gaining another member and a powerful spell and lots of items I'm not sure what else we could do?
Saying that i do understand that it's luck, and right now we have a bad team setup for the challenges we face. It may change next floor.
Also, good job with the writing

Not the biggest fan of eggs, but then I guess we shouldn't lose to spiders XD